Exact spherical-wave forward model for radio reflection from stratified media and implications for the anomalous-polarity events observed by ANITA
astro-ph.IM, astro-ph.HE, hep-ex, physics.class-ph, physics.ins-det
Submitted: 2026-08-17
Updated: 2026-08-27
Comments: 36 pages, 10 figures. Substantially revised and extended, including an expanded title and significant revisions following internal review. Submitted to Physical Review D; currently under review
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/
The gist: Radio detection of ultra-high energy particles relies on the propagation and reflection of broadband radio pulses at boundaries between natural media.
Terminology
Abstract
Radio detection of ultra-high energy particles relies on the propagation and reflection of broadband radio pulses at boundaries between natural media. In the Sommerfeld--Weyl treatment, a spherical wave is decomposed into plane-wave components and their reflection from a single homogeneous interface is calculated exactly. We extend that treatment to an arbitrary number of laterally uniform spherical layers. Both the spherical-wave decomposition of the source and the spherical geometry of the boundary are retained, while the reflection and transmission coefficients of the plane-wave components are replaced by the exact characteristic-matrix coefficients of the layered medium, evaluated at the local incidence angle on the spherical boundary. When the layer contrast is removed, the formalism recovers the single-boundary result to machine precision, and it reproduces the published spherical-surface reflectivity calculation to better than 1.1% at ten HiCal-2 elevation angles, with a mean deviation of 0.6%. We reproduce the measured HiCal-1 reflected pulses from their measured direct partners, with a best signed correlation of 0.83 and a median of 0.70 across 106 pairs, of which 101 show the expected polarity inversion. Applied to the six reported ANITA anomalous-polarity event geometries, the buried-layer refractive index required for a sign change of the reflection coefficient ranges from 1.68 at the steepest event to 3.8 -- 5.4 at the four near-horizon events. The full waveform calculation gives no non-inverted reflected pulse at any of these angles, showing that shallow, laterally uniform firn layering does not account for the polarity of the anomalous ANITA events. Because the formalism depends only on the complex refractive index of the medium, it applies more generally to isotropic, nonmagnetic stratified media, including ice, lunar regolith, and conducting layers.
Sources
- Radio detection of cosmic ray air showers in the digital era
- Radio emission from cosmic ray air showers: simulation results and parametrization
- Observation of the Askaryan Effect: Coherent Microwave Cherenkov Emission from Charge Asymmetry in High Energy Particle Cascades
- Observations of the Askaryan Effect in Ice
- The Antarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna Ultra-high Energy Neutrino Detector Design, Performance, and Sensitivity for 2006-2007 Balloon Flight
- Observation of Ultra-high-energy Cosmic Rays with the ANITA Balloon-borne Radio Interferometer
- Energy and Flux Measurements of Ultra-High Energy Cosmic Rays Observed During the First ANITA Flight
- Characteristics of Four Upward-pointing Cosmic-ray-like Events Observed with ANITA
- Observation of an Unusual Upward-going Cosmic-ray-like Event in the Third Flight of ANITA
- Unusual Near-horizon Cosmic-ray-like Events Observed by ANITA-IV
- Antarctic Surface Reflectivity Measurements from the ANITA-3 and HiCal-1 Experiments
- HiCal 2: An instrument designed for calibration of the ANITA experiment and for Antarctic surface reflectivity measurements
- Antarctic Surface Reflectivity Calculations and Measurements from the ANITA-4 and HiCal-2 Experiments
- General Treatment of Reflection of Spherical Electromagnetic Waves from a Spherical Surface and its Implications for the ANITA Anomalous Polarity Events
- Design and Initial Performance of the Askaryan Radio Array Prototype EeV Neutrino Detector at the South Pole
- Constraints on the Diffuse Flux of Ultra-High Energy Neutrinos from Four Years of Askaryan Radio Array Data in Two Stations
- A low-threshold ultrahigh-energy neutrino search with the Askaryan Radio Array
- Progress Towards a Diffuse Neutrino Search in the Full Livetime of the Askaryan Radio Array
- A search for the ultra high energy neutrinos with the low threshold phased array trigger system of the Askaryan Radio Array
- Observation of In-ice Askaryan Radiation from High-Energy Cosmic Rays
Related papers
- A signal dedispersion algorithm for imaging-based transient searches
- AVICA: A fully automated CASA pipeline for large volume VLBI data calibration
- Spectral Map Making with SPHEREx
- Long-Integration Magnetar Burst Observatory (LIMBO): Instrument Summary and Early FRB Rate Constraints
- Towards independent event horizon imaging of the supermassive black holes in M87 and the Milky Way
- A PINK update: Improvements to the CELEBI fast radio burst data reduction and analysis pipeline